Mexican Standoff!

Who gets the toy?
I will allow you one guess only.
Today's extra is Eve with Chloe - and Rosa trying to hide in the background.
We had Fiona, James & Annabelle plus Ali & Eve with Rosa this afternoon. I took Annabelle and Rosa for a walk, consecutively, not concurrently.
My reward was a Magnum ice cream lolly. Lovely!